Deeply Disappointing that Climate Bill Ignores Oireachtas Committee Recommendations
Absurd that Bill delays climate action for two more years
Stop Climate Chaos has welcomed the publication of the long-awaited Climate Action Bill but described as "deeply disappointing" the Government's rejection of proposals by an Oireachtas committee to strengthen the Bill. According to the coalition of environment, overseas aid, youth and faith groups, three key recommendations of the Oireachtas environment committee, which held comprehensive hearings on the draft Bill and produced an all-party report, have been ignored.
Commenting, Stop Climate Chaos spokesperson, Oisin Coghlan, said:
"It's deeply disappointing that the Government is ignoring the proposals of the all-party Oireachtas Committee.
"This legislation is urgent, Ireland's emissions are already off-track and we are two years without a climate action plan. It's now up to TDs and Senators to fix this Bill and pass it into law as quickly as possible."
The Bill does not include the Government's own definition of low carbon, it doesn't guarantee the independence of the Climate Advisory Council, and it doesn't include the principle of climate justice - all recommendations of the Oireachtas Committee, chaired by Labour TD, Michael McCarthy.
David Healy, Policy and Advocacy Coordinator with Oxfam Ireland, commented:
"The Government hasn't even included a line in the Bill to say the Climate Advisory Council will be 'independent in the performance of it's functions', the formulation used for the Fiscal Advisory Council. If guaranteed independence is good enough for advice on the fiscal budget why not for climate policy?"
The Government has also ignored the Committee's proposal to include climate justice in the Bill.
Niamh Garvey, Environmental Justice Policy Officer with Trócaire, commented:
"The Government has voiced support for the principle of climate justice at the UN and co-hosted a conference on the issue with Mary Robinson as part of Ireland’s EU presidency. Was that just lip service? Why is climate justice left out of the Bill?"
Stop Climate Chaos has been calling for "the principle of climate justice" to be one of the things that Ministers must have regard to when designing the national mitigation plan (section 3.2 of the Bill).
The only substantive change from the draft Bill produced by Phil Hogan a year ago is a negative one. The Government has delayed the adoption of a national mitigation plan with sectoral policy measures by at least another two years. Ireland's last emissions reduction plan expired at the end of 2012 just before our challenging 2020 EU targets came into force. The Government promised a new plan by early 2014. Then, last April Phil, Hogan's draft Bill mandated there be an action plan within 12 months of the climate law coming into force. Now, Minister Kelly's Bill gives the Government two years from the enactment to come up with actual measures to reduce emissions.
Oisin Coghlan concluded:
"It's absurd that the first consequence of the Climate Action Bill would be to delay climate action. It seems the Government wants to long-finger sectoral emissions reduction measures until after the next election. Our EU targets run from 2013-2020 and the Government is saying Ireland will adopt it's action plan to meet them sometime in 2017!"
The Bill now goes to the Oireachtas for debate, scrutiny, amendment and approval. As the Government has ignored the recommendations of the all-party Oireachtas environment committee, Stop Climate Chaos will be calling on TDs and Senators to fix the Bill and pass it into law as quickly as possible.
- The Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Bill can be downloaded here:http://bit.ly/ClimateBill2015
- Stop Climate Chaos's 4-page briefing on draft Bill should have been improved in this full Bill is here: http://www.foe.ie/download/pdf/scc_briefing_on_improving_the_climate_action_bill_november_2014.pdf
Campaigners express disappointment at another missed deadline on the Climate Bill
Government must recognise urgency of putting a framework in place to limit emissions
17 December 2014
After pitiful progress was made at international climate negotiations in Lima last weekend, campaigners have said they are disappointed to see yet another deadline pass on the introduction of climate legislation in Ireland. The Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Bill was expected to be published this week but it was dropped from the Cabinet’s agenda yesterday and will now not be published until January.
Commenting, Coordinator of Stop Climate Chaos Ciara Kirrane, said:
‘Deadlines set by government for the introduction of the climate Bill have been repeatedly missed over the past 2 years. Phil Hogan said the Bill would be introduced by the end of 2013 and last week the Taoiseach said the it would be published before the end of the current Dáil session. Moreover, the Statement of Government Priorities for 2014-2016 committed to the enactment of climate legislation before the end of 2014. The slippage is disappointing and frustrating, considering we are now two years without a climate strategy.
'At the UN climate negotiations in Lima last week, we saw a reluctance from governments to treat the climate crisis with the urgency required to meet a challenge of this scale. In order to stay below the internationally agreed temperature threshold of 2 degrees of warming we need to immediately reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Climate legislation provides a framework for achieving this and for ensuring accountability, which is why we have been campaigning for its introduction for the past number of years.
‘What we now need to see in January is a prioritisation of the Climate Bill. We also need to see significant improvements in many important areas of the Bill, especially relating to how low-carbon is defined and whether the advisory committee is truly independent. The Bill must, at a minimum, take into account the recommendations of the Joint Oireachtas Committee on the Environment, Culture and the Gaeltacht who consulted widely on the draft Bill last year and arrived at a set of recommendations that were agreed to by all parties.’
UN climate negotiations fail to deliver for the poorest
14 December 2014
Stop Climate Chaos has today criticised the outcome of the UN climate negotiations, which concluded early on Sunday morning. The negotiations began on 1 December in Lima, Peru and ran two days over schedule.
Commenting Ciara Kirrane, Coordinator of Stop Climate Chaos, said:
“The outcome today does nothing to support the poorest people around the world who are on the frontline of the climate crisis, a crisis they did not create. For the past two weeks, developed countries have been trying to undermine the negotiations by eroding core principles related to their historic responsibility for the climate change. They have succeeded in this regard and have pulled back on providing support to developing countries. The process was supposed to build momentum towards an equitable agreement next year in Paris but unfortunately the foundations for this have not been laid in Lima.
“As well as failing to ensure developed countries contribute the necessary financial and technological resources to developing countries to help them cope with climate impacts, the agreement also fails us all given the scale of the climate crisis. The science on climate change is irrefutable but the Lima Accord does not put us on a pathway to keep global temperatures below 2°C, a threshold beyond which dangerous climate impacts are expected.
“World governments remain far from where they need to be if they are to make an adequate equitable agreement to tackle climate change in Paris 12 months from now. Ireland did not show leadership this week in Lima. It was one of the only countries not to pledge support to the Green Climate Fund, something that must be addressed in the coming months. They have a chance to show they are serious about tackling climate change when they publish the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Bill this week, but it will depend on how strong the elements of the Bill are.”
Negotiations in a less than progressive place - Lima, Peru
Arriving at my first ever international climate change negotiations had all the markings of a daunting and overwhelming experience. Thousands of delegates, numerous negotiation streams, countless meetings and side events – not to mention the 28°C temperatures adding to the pressure inside the negotiation halls.
From Ciara Kirrane, Stop Climate Chaos Coordinator, in Lima, Peru.
I arrived on Saturday which, although still a formal day of negotiations, was a quieter and more subdued day compared to previous days, according to my colleagues who had been here since 1 December. As a way of getting to grips with the main sticking points in the negotiations, I attended a press conference organised by Third World Network and Friends of the Earth International.
The split between developed and developing countries seems, as ever, immense and is proving to be a significant stumbling block so far in the negotiations. Developing countries are calling for adaptation (the process of coping and living with the impacts of climate change) to be included in the new agreement on an equal footing to mitigation (emission reductions). This would be a big difference to the Kyoto Protocol, which focused only on mitigation obligations. Adapting to the impacts of climate change requires resources – both financial and technological – and developing countries are calling for this because they are already dealing with the impacts of a warmer world, a world that has already warmed by 0.8°C and will see a further 0.6°C increase in temperatures irrespective of what we do in the coming decades to reduce emissions.
Of course developed countries are resisting this, and are actively trying to reduce their responsibility for the climate crisis by introducing new terms and concepts which are not a part of the framework convention on climate change, such as ‘evolving’ Common But Differentiated Responsibilities (CBDR is a principle in the convention which recognises historic responsibility and varying levels of capacity to act). Developed countries seem to be employing not so subtle methods of intimidation, making threats that if developing countries push these issues too hard the talks could fail. Whether this situation will improve over the coming 5 days remains to be seen.
Aside from this somewhat dismal situation, the week ahead looks fascinating. Tomorrow, the Cumbre de los Pueblos – an alternative People’s Summit demanding climate justice, kicks off. It is being organised by Peruvian and international civil society organisations and will host a massive march on 10 December. Meanwhile an event tomorrow hosted by Shell will no doubt attract attention (stayed tuned for more info). Minister Alex White also arrives from Ireland tomorrow in advance of the high-level ministerial meetings happening from Tuesday to Thursday.
As the UN Climate talks get underway in Lima, campaigners call for leadership from developed countries
Stop Climate Chaos will be in Lima monitoring progress
1 December 2014
As the UN Climate talks get underway today in Lima, Peru climate campaigners in Ireland call for much needed leadership during the two week meeting. Stop Climate Chaos warns that unless delegations from developed countries make significant steps forward the talks will not progress, and the possibilities of achieving a global agreement in Paris next year will be even further away.
Ciara Kirrane, Coordinator of Stop Climate Chaos, said today:
"Unless the world's richest developed countries take responsibility for the climate change they have caused these negotiations will struggle to make progress. The proposals currently on the table fall far short of what is needed to prevent dangerous climate change. In order to address this, developed countries must put forward more ambitious quantified emission reduction objectives as well as clear contributions for climate finance and technology transfer to developing countries.
Ciara Kirrane, who will be arriving in Lima later this week, says Stop Climate Chaos will be eager to see developed countries, including Ireland, stepping up their levels of ambition:
"These talks take place against a backdrop of increasing concern about climate change. The scientific community has provided their most damning assessment to date of the state of the climate, while citizens around the world took to the streets in September to voice their fears about runaway climate change. Leaders and representatives of governments in Lima must heed these calls for action and put in place the necessary commitments to ensure this round of negotiations does not fail as so many other climate negotiations have in the past."
On World Food Day climate campaigners criticise government for seeking special treatment for agriculture in EU climate negotiations
16 October 2014
Ahead of next week's crucial EU summit, where the EU's 2030 climate package will be agreed, Stop Climate Chaos has criticised the government for seeking special treatment for Irish agriculture. The coalition of 28 development, environmental, youth and faith-based organisations are concerned that the proposed text for the European Council meeting on 23rd October (leaked on 14th October) will result in an exception being made for Irish agriculture on the false assumption that Irish exports contribute to solving global food insecurity.
SCC Coordinator Ciara Kirrane pointed out:
“The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has concluded that climate change poses very significant challenges to food security. However, the Irish government has tended to suggest that action to tackle climate change, rather than climate change itself, threatens food security by restricting production here in Ireland. The notion that Irish exports of beef and diary contribute to global food security has been consistently refuted by overseas aid agencies. It is very worrying to read the leaked text which implies a such a link."
Ciara Kirrane also criticised the lack of reference to sustainable food consumption in the draft conclusions:
“Reference to intensification of food production fails to take account of the social and environmental impacts of production including the climate impact. The leaked text ignores the role of sustainable food consumption, particularly reducing food waste and eating low-carbon food."
Stop Climate Chaos is calling on Heads of State and Government attending the European Council next week to make the following changes to the draft text:
- Recognise that climate change is the overwhelming threat to food security, not climate mitigation policies.
- Commit to sustainable food production and consumption, including minimisation of food waste and promoting sustainable diets.
Stop Climate Chaos hosts climate picnic as part of weekend of worldwide actions on climate change
On Sunday 21st September Stop Climate Chaos, and our friends in Climate Gathering and People's Climate Ireland, hosted a picnic in St Stephen's Green as part of a worldwide mobilisation highlighting the need for action on climate change. It was one of 2,646 events that took place in 162 countries around the world that weekend. More people took to the streets calling for climate action than on any other day in history. Events from New York City to Rio, London to Delhi showed that people everywhere want to see world leaders doing more to tackle climate change.
Close to 1,000 people turned up to the Picnic in central Dublin where they were greeted by live music, circus performers, artistic activities, games, face-painting and more. Messages were gathered from picnicers about the things they love that they don't want to see changed forever by climate change. RTE news were there and the Picnic featured in national newspapers Monday 22nd.
Follow the link (http://www.stopclimatechaos.ie/gallery) to see photos from the Picnic, while images captured from around the world are here https://www.flickr.com/photos/peoplesclimate/sets/. A short photofilm from the Picnic - put together by Trocaire - can be viewed here http://youtu.be/rv3rNKQa6j8
Come join us for the People's Climate Picnic - Sunday Sept 21st
In less than three weeks, in cities and towns around the world, people will be getting together to show they care about climate change. You can be part of this worldwide movement by joining us for:
The People's Climate Picnic
Sunday September 21st from 12-2pm @ The Bandstand, St. Stephen's Green, Dublin 2
Bring a friend, food or just come for fun but make sure you're there to be part of this historic moment. RSVP here!
Two days later, in New York, leaders from around the world will be meeting for a summit on climate change. Taoiseach Enda Kenny will be there and we want to send a strong message to him that people in Ireland care about climate change. We care that climate change will impact upon the things and places we all love. And we care that world leaders are not doing enough.
We'll be providing you with the means to do so on the day so join us on the 21st to make your voice heard.
And if you want to hear more about how climate change is affecting communities around the world right now join Trócaire, Friends of the Earth & Stop Climate Chaos on Thursday 11th September for a public talk on
Climate Justice: Exploring Indian and Kenyan experiences and responses to climate change.
Speakers from India and Kenya will be there on the night to talk first-hand about their experiences of, and solutions to, climate change.
Thursday 11th September, 7pm, Central Hotel, Exchequer Street, Dublin 2.
Numbers are limited so book your seat in advance to avoid disappointment.
We hope that you can join us for both events!
EPA's warnings about Ireland exceeding it's emissions targets makes a climate law all the more urgent
29 May 2014
Stop Climate Chaos has today said the government must heed warnings from the EPA and bring the climate Bill to the Dáil before the summer recess. The coalition said the EPA's projections that Ireland will exceed its EU 2020 target of reducing emissions by 20 per cent were worrying but not unexpected, given Ireland's national climate change strategy ran out in 2012 and there has been nothing guiding action since.
Ciara Kirrane, Coordinator of Stop Climate Chaos, said 'The projections from the EPA reinforce why Ireland needs climate legislation and why Stop Climate Chaos and our member organisations have been calling for a climate law since 2007. The government is not taking its EU targets seriously, preferring to risk financial penalties from the EU than taking steps to reduce emissions. Having a climate law in place would mean these choices are not as easy and that the government would have to account for its inaction.'
Ciara Kirrane continued 'The evidence shows that we are going in the wrong direction. As well as missing our 2020 target, it's likely our emissions will be even higher by 2030. The government has allowed climate change to drift off the agenda with the economic crisis. Exceeding our targets not only puts us at risk of hefty fines from the EU but it also fails to recognise the connection between climate inaction and poor economic growth in the future.'
'The introduction of robust climate legislation can turn this situation around, but only if it makes clear what we want to achieve by 2050 and has the independent oversight to ensure that this happens. Minister Hogan committed to the introduction of climate legislation by the end of 2013. It is now essential that the revised heads, published last month, be debated before the summer so that we can see the passing of a climate law as soon as possible. This will be a significant step towards putting Ireland on a path to a low carbon future.'
Internationally the pressure to agree steps towards achieving a global agreement on climate change in 2015 is increasing. Next week ministers from around the world will meet in Bonn to discuss domestic action on climate change and future commitments. The convening of ministers at this meeting reflects the scale of the challenge and the importance of agreeing a global deal in Paris at the end of 2015. Stop Climate Chaos is disappointed that Minister Hogan is not attending these talks with his international counterparts, meaning Ireland will have less of a role to play and reflecting his low level of commitment to the issue.
Civil society organisations disappointed that the Climate Bill does not go far enough
23 April 2014
Stop Climate Chaos today acknowledges the publication of the long awaited revised Heads of the climate Bill but says the minimal changes that have been made since its release last year are disappointing. The coalition says the next stages will be essential to strengthen the Bill.
Stop Climate Chaos, a coalition of 28 civil society organisations campaigning on climate change, have been calling for the introduction of climate legislation since 2007. Last year the Government introduced draft Heads of Bill that Stop Climate Chaos believed was 'too weak to work'. The NGO coalition had high hopes for the revised Heads published today, given the thorough consultation process facilitated by the Environment Committee last year.
Commenting today, Ciara Kirrane of Stop Climate Chaos, said "We are disappointed that the revised Heads do not show significant improvements in the areas most needed. The Body tasked with giving advice to government on climate change matters is not independent, despite the advice from the Environment Committee that all members should be independent of State or stakeholder interests. And while the revised Heads allows for the Expert Advisory Body to publish its own reports, this is merely good practice in a transparent and functioning system."
"The government hasn't taken the opportunity to provide a clear vision of what Ireland wants to achieve by 2050. The language used is of a 'low carbon transition' but nowhere in the Bill is this defined. A three page policy document also published today gives us some guidance, but this had no legal standing and can be ignored or disregarded by any government that sees fit."
The revised Heads of the Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Bill come at a time of mounting pressure, with warnings from the scientific community that business as usual will lead us to catastrophic climate change. Ms Kirrane continued "The warnings show that no country will be untouched by climate change, and in Ireland unfortunately we are set to experience more flooding, with the associated economic and emotional costs, if we do not cut our emissions dramatically. While we will all be more vulnerable to extreme weather it is the poorest and most marginalised around the world who will suffer most. Left unchecked, climate change will continue to negatively affect food production and human health, and has the potential to reverse many of the gains made in reducing poverty over the last decades."
Stop Climate Chaos Responds to IPCC Report on Impacts of Climate Change
Leading campaigners on climate change give reaction to major international report and outline increased flooding risks for Ireland
Ireland will face an increased risk of extreme weather events, with more coastal and river flooding, unless the Government steps up action to contain climate change and urges its international counterparts to do likewise. That's according to Stop Climate Chaos, a coalition of 28 civil society organisations, who today (31.03.14) held a public briefing on the IPCC report in the Project Arts Centre in Dublin.
Stop Climate Chaos was responding to the publication of the second of four reports by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the UN body for the assessment of climate change. The report was prepared by over 800 leading scientists from 39 different countries over the past two years. It focuses on the impacts of climate change already being experienced, as well as future risks and adaptation strategies, and shows that with no adaptation, coastal flooding in the 2080s is projected to affect millions more people in Europe per year, with the Atlantic, Northern and Southern European regions most affected.
According to the coalition, the increased flooding risk that comes with extreme weather events could spell chaos for Ireland's economy.
"The report looks at how climate change impacts on people, plants, animals, the environment and the economy - and how we can adapt," explained Niamh Garvey, spokesperson for SCC. "We enjoy a temperate climate in Ireland, but that does not mean that we are exempt from the direct impacts of climate change. If climate change continues unchecked, the weather in Ireland will become more volatile and floods will be commonplace.
"An increase in flooding would have a negative impact on our economy and our quality of life. Earlier this year, we witnessed first-hand the chaos wreaked by flooding on people's homes, businesses and day-to-day lives. We are also seeing rising insurance costs and growing unwillingness amongst investors to place assets in areas affected by flooding. These are serious issues for coastal and island economies like Ireland.
"Even more serious are the impacts that will be felt by the poorest communities around the world. This report shows that we will all be more vulnerable to extreme weather but that it is the poorest and most marginalised who will suffer most. Left unchecked, climate change will continue to negatively affect food production and human health, and has the potential to reverse many of the gains made in reducing poverty over the last decades."
Government Action Required
Ms. Garvey called on the Government to strengthen its proposed climate legislation and put in place immediate steps to ensure we meet our emissions reduction targets in response to the IPCC report.
"The focus must now be on ensuring comprehensive government action that avoids the worst impacts of climate change," she said. "The Government published draft climate legislation this time last year which Stop Climate Chaos described as 'too weak to work'. However much good work was done by the Oireachtas Environment Committee to improve the legislation and in the revised Bill due next month, the Government must implement its recommendations. . They must also work with their partners at EU and international levels to achieve a global deal on climate change which they have promised in 2015.
"Without further action In Ireland, we will have exceeded our 2020 emissions targets as early as next year.. This will leave Ireland, and the taxpayer, facing financial penalties as well as missing the economic opportunities in making the transition to a low carbon economy. Clearly, the costs of inaction or delayed action are substantial. The time to prevent extreme climate change and reduce our emissions is now."
Speaking in advance of the event Professor Barry McMullin, a leading expert in societal responses to climate change and chair of the Climate Change Committee of An Taisce, said: "By taking action now, we can save lives and money. As climate change worsens, it will make people poorer, hungrier and more ill due to having to contend with more extreme flooding, heat waves and droughts. Delaying action on climate change will cost more and be less effective. Acting now will save lives and deliver many other benefits, such as green jobs and more sustainable economies, to our communities and the environments they depend on."
Come Rain or Shine - Join us in the Project Arts Centre Monday 31st March 1pm
As the IPCC releases its latest report on the impacts of climate change, Stop Climate Chaos asks what it means for Ireland and the rest of the world.
Join us in the Project Arts Centre, Temple Bar on Monday 31st March at 1-2pm for a discussion of the IPCC's latest findings and their implications for extreme weather, human health, food production and other key sectors.
Speakers will include Professor Barry McMullin (Executive Dean, Faculty of Engineering and Computing, DCU) and experts from development agencies who are dealing with the impacts of climate change first hand. The discussion will be chaired by Paul Melia, Environment Correspondent - Irish Independent.
Stop Climate Chaos calls on the European People’s Party for stronger action on climate change
6 March 2014
As Dublin today plays host to the European People's Party congress, Stop Climate Chaos is calling on the leaders of some of Europe's most powerful countries to strengthen European action on climate change. The coalition is calling on delegates, including German Chancellor Angela Merkel and European Commission President José Manuel Barroso, to increase the ambition of the European Commission's 2030 Climate and Energy Framework proposal.
Ciara Kirrane from Stop Climate Chaos said 'Over the past year Europe has gotten a glimpse of how vulnerable we are to extreme weather events driven by climate change. Ireland, England and Wales have experienced their wettest winters on record and the floods that hit Germany and Central Europe last summer could become regular events if Europe does not act now to tackle climate change'.
'A climate and energy package that is in line with the science and ensures we contain climate change is what we need and expect from Europe. The package currently on the table is not nearly ambitious enough, and puts us in line to breaching what scientists believe are 'safe' levels of warming. European Commission President Barroso said in January that 'Climate action is central for the future of our planet' - we now want to see European leaders living up to that sentiment'.
Stop Climate Chaos says the 2030 Climate and Energy package needs to have stronger and more ambitious targets: at least a 55% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, a renewable energy target of 45% and an energy savings target of at least 40%.
Coalition says EU has rolled back on its climate leadership
22 Jan 2014
Stop Climate Chaos is deeply disappointed with the unambitious white paper released by the European Commission today on the EU's 2030 climate and energy framework. With low targets for greenhouse gas emission reductions and renewable energy, and a non-binding target for energy efficiency, the paper is a very disappointing and significant roll-back on the climate leadership previously demonstrated by the EU.
The White Paper proposes a 40% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030, a target Stop Climate Chaos argues is inadequate to contain global temperature increases. Ciara Kirrane, Coordinator of Stop Climate Chaos, said today 'This proposal is not in line with science, and what is actually needed to meet the challenge of climate change. NGOs across Europe are calling for a greenhouse gas emission reduction target of at least 55%. If ambition is not raised, the EU's international pledge to stay below 2 degrees of global warming is all but impossible'.
The renewable energy target, something Ireland has publically called for along with 7 other member states, also falls far short of the ambition needed. 'The EU is already on track to meeting, and indeed exceeding, its existing targets for greenhouse gas emission reductions and renewable energy by 2020, demonstrating the EU's ability to stretch itself further and apply the level of action that is commensurate with the scale of the climate challenge' Ms Kirrane added.
'In order to keep its international climate pledges, and ensure devastating climate impacts for the world's most vulnerable people are avoided, the EU must adopt three ambitious, binding targets for greenhouse gas emission reductions, renewable energy and energy savings. Sadly, such determination is lacking in this White Paper.'
Stop Climate Chaos Responds to Oireachtas Committee Report on Climate Change Bill
20 Nov 2013
The Stop Climate Chaos coalition has welcomed a report on climate change legislation, published today (20.11.13) by the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Environment, Community and Local Government. However, the coalition said the report "missed an opportunity" by not suggesting specific carbon emissions reduction targets should be set for 2050.
Today's report was published by the Oireachtas Committee following an intensive series of hearings with stakeholders in recent months. It focuses on the outline heads of the Climate Change and Low Carbon Development Bill, and includes a number of observations on how the draft Bill can be amended and strengthened.
Commenting today, Oisín Coghlan, spokesperson for Stop Climate Chaos, said: "We very much welcome this report, and the fact that it proposes a number of improvements to the draft Climate Bill. It concludes that the advisory committee overseeing Ireland's progress on tackling climate change should have a stronger role than that proposed in the draft legislation. This is something Stop Climate Chaos has consistently said: the new climate law must provide for a properly independent oversight committee.
"The report also contains welcome suggestions on how to ensure our climate policies are rolled out in an efficient and effective manner. In particular, it's good to see suggestions to reduce the timeframe for national action plans from seven years to five, and to develop a national roadmap for tackling climate change in advance of sectoral roadmaps.
"However, one disappointing aspect of the report is that it falls shy of proposing that specific carbon emissions reduction targets should be set for 2050. Stop Climate Chaos remains convinced that the simplest and most effective way to ensure Ireland adheres to its commitment to reduce carbon emissions is by enshrining a numeric target in law. The fact that this hasn't been proposed in this report is a missed opportunity."
Stop Climate Chaos also said the publication of the report was a test of the Government's commitment to political reform.
"Minister Phil Hogan and his Government colleagues have consistently said Oireachtas Committees will play a central role in developing legislation in the future, and in consulting with relevant stakeholders in doing so," said Oisín Coghlan. "This is the process through which today's report has been developed. Therefore, we expect the Government to take this report's conclusions on board in preparing the final Bill. This will be a real test of their commitment to political reform."
Stop Climate Chaos is a coalition of 28 civil society organisations, including leading NGOs such as Trócaire, Concern, Oxfam, Christian Aid and Friends of the Earth. Further information is available at www.stopclimatechaos.ie.